MakeVictoriaBetter

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Two very different schools (of thought), including a drive-only elementary!

This is the first of (likely) two posts, today, that will explore some on-going themes on MVB -- related to the contrasting perspectives used to (try to) make our cities better. 

The other post should have probably come first, and both involve a little more text and a little less pizazz than recent posts. But, you'll live.

Rene Johnston / Toronto Star
Two schools.

1. You cannot be dropped off at school in a car (pictured above).

2. You cannot not be dropped off at school in a car.

The first, in Milton, Ontario, is trying to "set the culture to begin with [in this new school].... We know we aren't going to get 100 per cent compliance, but if we can get 90 per cent, I'm thrilled."

Great -- and in Ontario no less!

The second, in Saratoga Springs, NY, has a no-biking policy and reproached a student and his mum for biking 7 miles to school on National Bike to Work Day.
School officials took her son’s bike and stored it in the boiler room. They told her she would have to return with a car to retrieve the bike later in the day. [the Saratogian]
Not so great. That's quite depressing, actually, in an amusing kind-of-way.

Let's take the example of the second school to explore these two perspectives/approaches to... 'bettering', a little more.

The family:
For Marino [mum] and her family... the policy is at odds with other attitudes in the city.

“What I’m looking for, at least for right now, is that a child accompanied by an adult could ride their bike to [the school],” she said. “Hopefully they will create a better scenario for kids to walk and bike.” [the Saratogian]
The principal:

“I would be a nervous wreck every day if kids were riding to school,” [the principal] said. “Traffic isn’t bumper to bumper, but it’s non-stop.
... While traffic is one concern, Byrne said he also worries about children traveling unsupervised through the community.
“If you look at the North Broadway route that the parent used that day... I don’t know how you say to the community at large that is a safe area.”
... He pointed out an incident several years ago where John Regan attempted to abduct a student at Saratoga Springs High School.
“It’s that one-time occurrence that will have everyone wringing their hands,” Byrne said. “I’m a little conservative on this one. If anything happened, it would weigh on me for the rest of my life.” [the Saratogian]
  Head in the sand -- South Park

To me, this is a great example to help make explicit two developing themes on MVB, which have definitely featured on recent discussions regarding bettering Shelbourne and bike helmet legislation.

The themes (the first one is most relevant, in this post):

1. Unless you are pushing for regressive or glacier-speed change, we need committed individuals that are willing to stand up and accept responsibility for short-term 'failure' and criticism in exchange for long-term and much greater gain.

Which is the alternative to this example: Ball-less, band-aid solutions that make people feel all warm and fuzzy -- which they don't realize is actually just due to their increasing waste line.

 
 mymoratorium.wordpress.com


2. Car-oriented perspectives (actions, and policies) perpetuate themselves. Human-oriented perspectives (actions, and policies) perpetuate themselves. 

One step backwards, two step forwards. Or, with perpetuation, one step back, continual forward stepping.

For example:
Problem: A commuter street is regularly clogged with traffic and unsafe for pedestrians and cyclists.

Solution: Remove a vehicular lane in exchange for cycle lanes and streetscape improvements. This means a step back to face traffic problems and angry yokels for a month or two. There might even be an accident and congestion (which would never have previously happened)! Then, take several steps forward and reap the rewards of better traffic flow, more active transport, a cleaner environment, a nicer streetscape for pedestrians, cyclists, and so businesses, etc...
This forward-thinking solution is in contrast to BAND AID (or ball-less or politically-driven) solutions, which simply cover up the symptom(s) of a greater problem.

 conservationbytes.com

For example:
Problem: Regular clashes between a fast moving, 3000-pound metal objects and a much smaller lump of flesh (i.e., people) on a aluminum rocking horse.
BANDAID: Let's put helmets on the cyclists, sell a lot of reflective clothing, and teach them to expect the unexpected from drivers.
That will solve the problem! Brilliant! Three inches of foam and some reflective strips will do the trick And, for goodness sake, cyclists, stay out of the way!


In light of attention spans, I shall conclude:

Yes, I am sure that the conditions around this school in New York (state) are not particularly people-friendly. However, admitting defeat and establishing ball-less, brain-less policies that only perpetuate negative attitudes and a car-oriented environment are not the way forward.

With change, lots of people will be angry, some people will be negatively effected, and one or two serious accidents might even occur -- "because" of such changes (because none happen now, I'm sure) -- and the yokels will be up in arms.

However, in the words of Howe Gelb, that's how things get done. (And no, any illogical detractors, I am not referring to 'we cannot let a few lives stop progress'; that would be a gross misinterpretation.)

What we need is preventative action that builds a base for this 'perpetual' human-oriented cycle to grow from.

--

On the bright side of things for the US:

DOT, First Lady & Childhood Obesity Task Force share important goal: Let's Move!

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Not for the faint of heart -- Helmetless Cycling Images!

My facebook-based debate on cycling helmet legislation continues to go on. You can read my post about why I think helmet legislation should be repealed, here.

In light of my detractors pointing out that cycling is terribly unsafe and that helmets are a must when moving forward with promoting cycling, I wanted to post some images that I came across, this morning, that not only reflect the savage attitudes and behaviours of the Dutch but also reflect my irresponsible, 'bohemian' vision for Victoria.

Those with sensitive stomachs should advert their eyes, because this is pretty shocking stuff.

A typical paint job for the Death School Buses. (schlijper.nl)

All of the remaining horror images are from amsterdamize.com

He'll shortly require that ice cream to soothe his skull.
Euthanasia is legal, too.

Pointing to wear they will fall, next.

The end of Romeo and Juliet, Amsterdam-style.

Is she pushing her off the bike? The lack of a helmet is enough, woman!

Euthanasia #2: Tears of Sorrow.

The new Chrysler Deathwagon

Sarcasm aside, we are a long, long way from, in my opinon, acceptable levels of cycling and driving in Victoria.

I do not think that removing helmet laws will instantly lead to some cycle-topia. However, I am certain that it will increase cycling, thereby making cycling more safe (and providing all of the other benefits that go with more cycling and less driving), which in turn will increase cycling, bike infrastructure, and then the 'cycle' will just perpetuate itself -- just like it has for cars over the past 60 years.

Bicycle helmet laws? No, car helmet laws!


I coincidentally found this on Copenhagenize.com after a healthy debate over bicycle helmet legislation, yesterday. It was too good not to post about!

You are probably laughing at this just like I am, but this is the point: Driving is far more dangerous (in terms of fatalities and serious head injuries) than cycling -- for you, your children, or anyone else -- and that's irrefutable.

So, if you support mandatory bicycle helmets, then you should be actively striving for legislation on car helmets. What's the difference? Nothing.

Here are ten reasons why you should consider wearing a helmet in your car:

Also:
"If helmets should be mandatory anywhere it's inside cars. Driving is the only thing most of us do that's really dangerous, with almost 50,000 deaths a year in North America. Going for a drive is like going to war - and we should probably wear combat helmets - especially teenagers". Josh Freed, The Gazette, Montreal, 17 February 2007.
John also suggests a protective toque for winter activities: "Crossing busy streets and falling on icy sidewalks are commonplace dangers for everyone when the snow is flying." And, "Falling ice and snow off large buildings have been known to strike many unsuspecting pedestrians."

And helmets for on the bus: "No seatbelt on buses! Why not safety helmets?"

Again, this sounds laughable, but mandatory cycle helmets are no different.

From Copenhagenize.com:
The only reason that the two Australian motoring helmets never made any real impact is that the automobile industry wouldn't touch them with a ten-foot pole. It would be a catastrophe for sales if we started telling people that driving is dangerous. 1.2 million deaths a year and many more injuries. Goodness, no. That's bad marketing.
Car helmets for all!



--

Related:

Bike Helmet Laws -- stoopid

Not for the Faint of Heart: Helmetless cycling images

Monday, May 10, 2010

'The Province' (Newspaper) against cycling - more yokels.

Check out the full article link and commentary over at Vincent's Victoria.

The Province on Canada.com

I would generally be repeating myself it I were to respond overly much to the editorial. Needless to say, it's a reflection of the prevailing ignorant, counterproductive, backwater thinking that so many people subscribe to.

Anyways, I will save such re-hashing of my 'side' for future posts.

In the mean time, here is a quick summary:

- The Province (newspaper) ran an editorial criticizing Vancouver's plan to commit 1/3 of their road budget to cycling infrastructure and improvement -- bike lanes, etc. -- in order to increase cycling.

- The editorial suggests that, because most people use motorized transport and because they are often stuck in traffic on 'inefficient' roads, it's unfair and undemocratic to give road space to cyclists.

Ha! Wow: yokels are everywhere.

I agree with Vincent's commentary on the situation, so just go there for more info.

I have lots more to say on the matter, but I'd like to quickly point out cyclists -- as well as every other non-driving citizen -- pays road tax too, and so subsidizing driving. 


On the bright side, this is an awesome proposal, and I will take back everything that I have said (negative) about Vancouver, should this go through!

Sunday, May 9, 2010

Bike helmet laws -- stoopid.


Why?

In brief:

Cycling isn't any more dangerous than being a pedestrian or driving. Helmet laws cause far less people to cycle, and the benefits of more people cycling (more often) far, far, far outweigh the potential safety benefits of helmets.


I don't want to present you with an essay, here. Easy-to-read, fully-referenced reports can be found here and here. Also, a collection of highly-readable and image-friendly brochures/reports can be found here.

Instead, here is the gist with accompanying quotes/images.

Enforced helmet legislation is 'stoopid' because:

1. People are FAR more likely to cycle without helmet laws (in every example worldwide, including BC):

http://www.ctcyorkshirehumber.org.uk/campaigns/velo.htm

2. The individual and public health gains from more cycling FAR outweigh any potential safety gain from helmet laws:
Moderate cycling has many physical and mental benefits (BMA 1992, 8) by reducing the risk [by over 50%] of developing heart disease (9), diabetes, high blood pressure, colon cancer and depression, and helping to control weight and increase fitness.
Dr Hillman from the UK's Policy Studies Institute calculated the life years gained by cycling outweigh life years lost in accidents by a factor of 20 to 1 (10).
3. Beyond health, the social, economic, cultural, and environmental benefits of more cyclists/cycling far outweigh the potential safety benefits of helmet legislation (citation: lif).

4. The more people cycle, the safer it is. Safety in numbers.


5. The actual safety benefits of helmets are under dispute

6. Bicycle accident rates increase with helmet use
For example, in the state of Western Australia... the annual cyclist death toll from 1987 to 1991 (pre-law) averaged 7.6 fatalities per year. From 1993 to 1997 (post-law) it was 6.4 fatalities per year, representing a 16% reduction [2]. However... cycling declined in Western Australia by approximately 30% during the 1990s following mandatory helmet law enforcement [3]. Thus, relative to cycle use, fatalities went up, not down.
[Why?] There is a good deal of circumstantial evidence that helmeted cyclists are more likely to crash, and data from one study [4] suggests that those wearing a helmet are more than 7 times likely to hit their heads if they do.
7. Risk of accident and serious head injury from cycling is not high


Maybe we should have walking and driving helmet laws?

8. If you are worried about your safety or cycling for sport, then you and/or your child can still wear one!

9. It violates people's personal freedom and beliefs (e.g., more plastic in landfills, etc.)

10. You'll save way more tax dollars and lives through healthy living than through helmets.

11. I'm sure there's more.


Seems like a no-brainer to me.


I will leave off with the following quote from an Australian woman who has been cycling all her life without a helmet, including over 15 years during mandatory helmet legislation. She was finally ticketed for not wearing a helmet, recently, and is taking the state to court over the law:
... by prosecuting cycling, which is beneficial to health, sedentary lifestyles have been encouraged which in turn have led to worse health outcomes and greater costs for the community.

Undoubtedly, Australia has the worst public cycling participation rate in the world, and instead [of doing something about it] has ignorantly embraced the greatest health risk of them all -- inactivity. I truly believe that... my conduct was and is a question of my survival. Therefore... it was and is necessary for me to cycle and to cycle without a helmet in order to prevent severe brain injury and / or death 

(check out the ever-enjoyable copenhagenize.com for more on this story)

Your thoughts?

---

See these follow up posts:

Helmetless Cycling Images: Not for the Faint of Heart!

Bicycle helmet laws? No, car helmet laws!

Space used by different modes of transportation

I've shown this image twice in previous posts, already. So, the point has been made, but I just found this one with the accompanying numbers -- the part I have been looking for.

I like this:



No bike helmet law post on the way.

Saturday, May 8, 2010

Replace parking with housing in James Bay? Not if the yokels can help it.

image from the Times Colonist Victoria

As I think I conveyed in my Bureaucracy vs. Balls post, I believe the democratic process has its limitations as a decision-making tool.

Why? Because most people are uninformed (ignorant) on most topics and just react with emotion when an issue might even seemingly affect them.

They durk ur jahbs!

Let's give an example:

Victoria City Council is considering an application from a James Bay apartment building owner that proposes replacing a parking structure to build more housing. (Thanks to Vincent at Vincent's Victoria for catching this one.)

An innovative (for Victoria), win-win idea in my opinion.

Proposal:
- Replace a two-story parking structure with a 4-story, 15-unit building.
- Reduce parking to 56 rather than the required 140 spots for 108 units.
 Why:
- The owner says that there is and only ever has been 81 parking spots. "Of that 81, a very large percentage sit vacant all day every day. So all we're basically saying is if we've got a vacant parking lot there that someone is not using for whatever reason, then would it not be better served for everyone if it was a building rather than an empty parking lot?"
Uhh... Yes? Of course.
-  To makes things better, though, the owner is offering initiatives such as 25 car-share memberships, parking for 47 bikes, and new co-op car to be located on site.
Great!

Not so fast.

Response:
- City staff recommended that the application be denied and is taking it to a public hearing.
- And, Victorians on timescolonist.ca are up in arms!!!!
 Purposely re-posted. Dey durk our parkin'!
 Here are some gems from those readers:
This Mayor and most of his council are totally off the rails... What next? Please give us an election before this council turns JB and Fairfield into ghettoes [sic].
First goes the parking, then come the gangs!

This one is more thoughtful (i.e., long) but equally illogical:
I lived on St. James Street [where this is] about 15 years ago and there was no parking then; this will only make it worse. Apartment building owners should have to provide parking for all units in their building FOR FREE!!

Note to Mr. Tinney....if there's nowhere to park; people will NOT rent your apartments. You're shooting yourself in the foot on this one.

...the James Bay Neighbourhood Association was formed to... keep the ambience of James Bay by keeping as many houses as possible and not destroy the "neighbourhood" feel by slamming up a bunch of boxes!!!!!
So, let's get this straight.

1. Someone else should have to pay for people's parking -- even if they don't have/use a car.

2. We should prevent this owner from 'shooting himself in the foot', because he obviously hasn't thought about what he's doing.

3. The ambiance of James Bay will be better served by a parking structure than a 4-story apartment building (with people inside) that encourage active transportation.

Yeah, that makes sense to me.

Well, sarcasm aside, I am going to try to leave this as a post about the news and the yahoos rather than getting too into a discussion on parking and its impacts on our city. However, I will end with the importance of a quote from Mayor Fortin re the proposal.
It's a precedent. How do we balance those interests of a local community -- liveable, walkable, affordable living -- [with] the need for cars?"
To me, this is the issue in a nutshell.

Needs of community vs. need for cars.

a) less cars = more livable, enjoyable, people-friendly communities

b) less parking and car infrastructure = shorter distances and so more walkable communities

c) less parking (adds at least 15% to real estate/rental costs) = more affordable community

Seems like a pretty obvious solution. People or cars?

Besides, we're talking about JAMES BAY: You're either really old and not shuffling past Thrifty's and Heron Rock, or you aren't really old and work downtown, which is approximately less-than-a-car-ride away.

--

A discussion of parking shall come soon, including how parking reduces density, increases distances, and so reduces walkability, bikability, transit-ability; increases development cost and so encourages sprawl; reduces affordability for buyers, renters, and business owners; encourages driving and restricts active transport; creates environmental problems (e.g., heat sinks, drainage, pollution run-off); ruins the streetscape and is aesthetically not-pleasing, etc...